--- title: "Insurance agencies in Fayetteville, NY" description: "11 insurance agencies in Fayetteville, NY, with addresses, phone numbers and opening hours. Call a few for quotes and compare." url: "https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/" lang: "en" image: "https://riskado.com/og/state-new-york.jpg" alternates: es: "https://riskado.com/es/agencias/new-york/fayetteville.md" --- # Insurance agencies in Fayetteville, NY Fayetteville has 11 insurance agencies in one ZIP code: 10 local or independent offices and 1 Assurant office. 3 are listed for auto insurance and 2 for health insurance. 1 office is open on Saturday and 1 on Sunday. 7 of the 11 have a website. New York drivers can start with [New York car insurance requirements](https://riskado.com/new-york-car-insurance-requirements/) and the guide to [New York no-fault insurance](https://riskado.com/new-york-no-fault-insurance/), which explains a coverage you will hear about on a first call. For a price picture, see the [average cost of car insurance in New York](https://riskado.com/average-cost-of-car-insurance-in-new-york/). If you live outside Fayetteville, [insurance agencies in Manlius](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/manlius/) are listed too. - [All agencies](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/) - [Auto insurance (3)](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/auto-insurance/) - [Health insurance (2)](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/health-insurance/) Showing 10 of **11** agencies RiskadoInsurance agency Assurant Fayetteville Fayetteville, NYassurant.com Insurance agency ### [Assurant Fayetteville](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/assurant/) 212 Highbridge St # D, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 637-4232](tel:+13156374232) RiskadoAuto insurance agency David Herrington - State Farm Insurance Agent Fayetteville, NYdave24x7.com Auto insurance agency ### [David Herrington - State Farm Insurance Agent](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/david-herrington-state-farm-insurance-agent/) 5005 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 446-2886](tel:+13154462886) RiskadoInsurance agency Farm Family Life Insurance Co Fayetteville Fayetteville, NYamericannational.com Insurance agency ### [Farm Family Life Insurance Co Fayetteville](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/farm-family-life-insurance-co/) 222 Highbridge St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 637-0284](tel:+13156370284) RiskadoInsurance agency Fayetteville Insurance Fayetteville, NY Insurance agency ### [Fayetteville Insurance](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/fayetteville-insurance/) 7153 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 579-3000](tel:+13155793000) RiskadoInsurance agency Gregory J. DeMario Representing Farm Family Fayetteville, NYmlagents.americannational.com Insurance agency ### [Gregory J. DeMario Representing Farm Family](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/gregory-j-demario-representing-farm-family/) 222 Highbridge St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 637-3045](tel:+13156373045) RiskadoAuto insurance agency Lori Mullen - State Farm Insurance Agent Fayetteville, NYsfautoquote.com Auto insurance agency ### [Lori Mullen - State Farm Insurance Agent](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/lori-mullen-state-farm-insurance-agent/) 6848 E Genesee St Unit 1, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 446-4432](tel:+13154464432) RiskadoAuto insurance agency Miller Agency Of New York Inc Fayetteville, NY Auto insurance agency ### [Miller Agency Of New York Inc](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/miller-agency-of-new-york-inc/) 700 E Genesee St Building E, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 446-5444](tel:+13154465444) RiskadoInsurance agency Miller Hy Fayetteville, NY Insurance agency ### [Miller Hy](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/miller-hy/) 7000 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 446-5221](tel:+13154465221) RiskadoInsurance agency Nationwide Insurance: Thomas J Heister Clu Fayetteville, NY Insurance agency ### [Nationwide Insurance: Thomas J Heister Clu](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/nationwide-insurance-thomas-j-heister-clu/) 333 Brooklea Dr, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 637-4330](tel:+13156374330) RiskadoHealth insurance agency PointGuard Advisors Network Fayetteville, NYpointguardadvisors.com Health insurance agency ### [PointGuard Advisors Network](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/fayetteville/pointguard-advisors-network/) 108 Buchman Cl Cir Suite 100, Fayetteville, NY 13066 [(315) 370-9965](tel:+13153709965) ## Nearby towns - [Insurance agencies in De Witt](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/de-witt/) (1) - [Insurance agencies in Manlius](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/manlius/) (6) - [Insurance agencies in East Syracuse](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/east-syracuse/) (18) - [Insurance agencies in Jamesville](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/jamesville/) (1) - [Insurance agencies in Syracuse](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/syracuse/) (170) - [Insurance agencies in Chittenango](https://riskado.com/agencies/new-york/chittenango/) (3) [Run an agency in Fayetteville that is not listed? Add your agency](https://riskado.com/agencies/add-your-agency/)